Replacement decisions on this side of the corridor mostly get made in the wrong season. A heater that has been marginal for two winters fails on the first cold weekend of a holiday, and the swap then happens under pressure.
Reading the end of a tank
Age alone is not the signal. What matters is what the unit shows: a shell that has wept at a seam, a base ringed with rust, water in a pan that keeps coming back after the fittings are checked, or a relief valve that discharges when nothing is wrong with the valve.
On a seasonal building, add one more: a heater that was drained and refilled each year and now leaks at a fitting nothing was done to.
Matching the replacement
Fuel first — gas, propane or electric — then the space. A closet install and an open utility room take different units, and a building that freezes needs either freeze protection or a drain-down routine.
Capacity comes after that, sized to how many people stay at once rather than to the building's square footage.
The parts people forget
A pan with a drain line to somewhere visible, a service valve on the cold inlet, unions so the next swap is not a cut-and-solder job, and seismic strapping. County inspection covers the strapping, the relief piping, the venting, the clearances and combustion air.
Permits and inspection
Replacement is permitted work in Tuolumne County, reviewed under the 2025 California Building Standards Code. Apply through the Building Division's online portal; the office in Sonora is at 48 Yaney Ave and the department answers on 209-533-5637.
Inspections are booked on 209-533-5940, with requests in before 3 p.m. the working day ahead.
Getting the old one out
A drained steel tank is heavy and awkward, and it has to leave the way the new one came in. Check the road before the day: a soft shoulder after rain or a drifted corner can stop a loaded vehicle where an empty one got through.
Old units are taken away for scrap rather than left on the parcel, which is also what the county expects to see when the site is inspected.