Replacement on a multi-building property is a scheduling exercise as much as a plumbing one. The buildings that fail are rarely the ones with the easiest access.
Deciding it is the end
Three signals settle it. A shell that has been repaired once and is leaking again. A tank whose recovery no longer meets the busiest window, even after flushing. A unit whose parts are no longer made.
Age supports the decision but does not make it — a well-kept tank at fifteen years can outlast a neglected one at eight.
Keeping the building in service
Where two units serve one building, the swap can proceed one at a time: isolate the failed unit, run the survivor, and confirm the survivor can carry the peak. A building with a single unit has no such option, which is why a spare unit or a temporary rental is worth costing in.
Between the seasons
Spring and autumn are the practical windows. In summer the building is occupied and the work competes with guests; in winter the drive may not be passable and the water is off.
Booking the replacement for the shoulder month means the inspection happens before the first busy week, not after it.
What changes with the new unit
A modern unit in place of an old one usually needs a different vent arrangement, a pan with a drain, and a pressure-only or combined relief valve piped to a safe discharge. Where the fuel is propane, the orifices are matched to it.
Seismic strapping is required, and in Tuolumne County it is one of the items the inspector looks for, with the rest being combustion air, clearances, venting and relief piping.
Paperwork and inspection
Apply through the Building Division's portal under the 2025 California Building Standards Code; the Sonora office is at 48 Yaney Ave and the department number is 209-533-5637.
Book the inspection on 209-533-5940 with a day's notice before 3 p.m. Multiple buildings mean multiple inspections, and they can be requested for the same visit.
The haul-out
Old tanks are heavy, and a loaded trailer on a soft shoulder is how a replacement day goes wrong. The drive is checked the week before, not on the morning.