Electric water heaters fail quietly. There is no flame to watch and no pilot to relight, so the symptoms are indirect: no hot water, not enough, a breaker that will not stay set, or a unit that runs and runs without keeping up.
Start at the breaker
A breaker that trips immediately on reset points at a shorted element or a wiring fault. A breaker that holds but the unit stays cold points toward the element circuit, a thermostat or the high-limit switch.
The high-limit is a safety cut-out. When it has tripped, it tripped for a reason — usually a thermostat that stuck closed and let the tank overheat. Resetting it without finding out why is how it trips again.
Elements and sediment
Elements sit inside the tank and heat the water directly. Sediment coats them, which insulates them from the water and makes them run hotter than they should; eventually they fail or the tank beneath them corrodes.
On well supply, this is the common sequence: sediment builds, the lower element works harder, recovery slows, then the element fails. Replacing the element without flushing leaves the new one in the same conditions.
Thermostats and recovery
A thermostat that reads high or low gives the wrong amount of heat. A unit that produces lukewarm water and never recovers is often a thermostat or a failed element rather than a tank problem.
Two-element tanks have upper and lower thermostats that interact, and diagnosing one without the other produces wrong conclusions.
What is worth repairing
Elements, thermostats, high-limits, gaskets and valves are all replaceable. A leaking tank is not. An older unit with a failed element and heavy sediment in a corroded tank is a case where the repair is throwing money at the wrong part.
Safety
Water and electricity in the same enclosure is the reason the breaker goes off before anything is opened. If water is at the element plate or the wiring compartment, the unit stays off until it is assessed.