An electric heater in Bumblebee has no flame and no flue to blame. The circuit, the elements, the thermostats and the water inside the tank account for nearly every failure, and the order of diagnosis barely changes.
Reading the breaker
Trips the instant it is reset: a shorted element or a wiring fault. Leave it off and have it tested.
Holds, but the tank stays cold: the element circuit, a thermostat, or a high-limit that has opened.
Trips after the unit has been running: an element that shorts once hot.
Thermostats and the high-limit
The high-limit is a one-shot cut-out, and it opens because the tank got too hot. The usual reason is a thermostat that stuck closed — so the safety is a symptom, not the fault.
Two-element tanks have upper and lower thermostats that work together. Testing one in isolation produces a confident wrong answer, which is how the wrong part gets bought.
Sediment on a private well
Well supply leaves material in the bottom of the tank, and the lower element sits in it. Coated, the element cannot transfer heat to the water efficiently, so it overheats, hums and eventually fails.
A replaced element in a scaled tank is a temporary fix. Flushing first is what makes the replacement last.
Voltage and long runs
A rural service with a long run to the building can deliver less than the heater expects under load. That shows up as a unit that never quite keeps up, and it is measured rather than guessed.
The verdict
On a sound tank, the answer is a part. On a tank with heavy scale, a consumed anode and a weeping base, the honest answer is a replacement — and saying so before the parts are ordered is the whole point of the diagnosis.