Storage tanks are still the commonest unit in these cabins, and a tank in an intermittently occupied building ages differently from one in a house that is lived in every day.
Standing heat in an empty building
The tank keeps its water hot whether anyone is there or not. In a building that is empty for eight months, that is eight months of heat loss with no hot water drawn, and the recovery cost on arrival is the least of it.
It is the argument for a smaller tank, better insulation on the unit and the pipes, or a different technology entirely. It is not an argument for turning the tank off and leaving water in it through a freeze.
The anode, on this water
The rod sacrifices itself so the lining does not. Private well water, often hard and sometimes aggressive, spends it faster than the generic guidance assumes.
Pulling and inspecting the rod is a small job that decides whether a tank has years left or months.
Sediment and the rumble
Minerals settle at the bottom. Under a burner they trap water that boils and pops; around an element they insulate it and drive it hotter than it should run.
Flushing through the drain until the water clears is the routine, and on this supply the interval is set by what the drain shows.
The end of a tank
A weeping seam, a rusted base, water that returns to the pan after the fittings have been ruled out. Those are the end, and no repair changes them.
The one thing worth doing at that point is correcting what shortened the tank's life — a leaking pan, a damp floor, missing strapping, a relief valve that has been dripping for years.
Repair or replace
A thermostat, an element, a dip tube, a T&P valve, a drain valve, a gas control: all replaceable, all worth it on a sound shell. The judgment is about the shell, and it is made by looking at it rather than by the age on the label.