A leak in a creek-bottom crawlspace is worse than the same leak in a garage. Water collects, it stays, and the space it fills is where the wiring and the base of the building are.
Stop it from outside the wet space
Shut the valve feeding the tank from the cold side. If the water keeps coming, shut the main. Then take the power off at the breaker, or turn the gas control to off.
Standing water plus electrical equipment is the reason the sequence is water first, then power, and never the other way round while someone is standing in it.
A split tank
Once the shell has failed, there is no repair. The emergency work is stopping the supply, getting the space dry, and arranging the replacement. A tank that let go in a crawlspace usually takes a pan, a base and some insulation with it.
Gas
Smell of gas or a CO alarm: everyone out, then the gas utility and 911. In a crawlspace, nobody goes in to look for the source.
When the honest answer is tomorrow
A heater that has stopped producing hot water, a pilot that will not hold with no smell, a drip in a pan that is catching it. Those are next-day calls, and on a road that may be soft, icy or drifted, they are also the ones that make sense.
Preventing the call
A working shut-off, a pan that drains somewhere visible, and a base that keeps the tank out of the water. In this building type, those three prevent most of the emergencies that would otherwise arrive at night.