Skip to content
Something's wrongBy Water Heater Repair Strawberry, CA

Why a water heater pilot light keeps going out

A pilot that will not stay lit is usually a thermocouple, air in the line, or a venting fault. How to tell which — and when to stop relighting.

A pilot that will not hold is the most common gas call there is, and the good news is that the cause is usually one of three things. The bad news is that one of them is a safety problem, and it is the one people skip.

First, the safe answer

If you smell gas, or a carbon-monoxide alarm sounds, the building empties. Then the gas utility and 911. No relighting, no searching for the source indoors, no opening a valve to listen.

If there is no smell and no alarm, one relight following the label on the unit is reasonable. If it goes out again, stop.

Cause one: air in the line

A unit that has been off for months, a propane tank that ran low, a line that was worked on. Air reaches the pilot and it will not hold until the gas arrives.

This is the ordinary spring scenario in a building that sat empty all winter, and it resolves on the first or second attempt.

Cause two: the thermocouple

The thermocouple is the small probe in the flame. It generates the tiny current that holds the gas valve open, and when it weakens the valve closes as soon as the button is released.

The symptom is specific: the pilot lights, burns while the button is held, and dies when it is let go. It is an inexpensive part, and on an accessible unit it is a short job.

Cause three: venting and combustion air

A blocked flue, a disconnected vent, a room with no air supply, a downdraft on a windy ridge. The pilot lights and then dies when the main burner comes on and the products of combustion have nowhere to go.

This is the cause worth taking seriously. The signs are soot at the draft hood, condensation on nearby windows, a smell of exhaust, or a flame that lifts and flutters. A unit in that state stays off until the flue is corrected.

In a cabin sealed for the season, this is more likely than in a house that breathes all year, which is why gas water heater repair treats venting as part of the pilot diagnosis rather than a separate question.

Less common causes

A dirty pilot orifice, a failing gas control, low supply pressure from a regulator or an undersized line, or moisture in a propane system. Each is tested rather than guessed, and pressure is measured at the appliance.

What the visit involves

The pilot assembly is cleaned and the thermocouple tested, the flue checked for obstruction and draft, gas pressure measured at the inlet and manifold, and the burner observed through a full cycle. On a unit that has been sitting, that sequence answers the question in one visit.

Repeated pilot failures on an old unit, with a rusted flue collar or a gas valve that no longer holds, are the point where repair stops being the cheaper answer — the decision covered in repair or replace.

Get in touch

Pilot out again this morning?

One relight is fine, a second is a fault. Tell us whether there is any smell of gas before anything else is said.

Questions about this article

How many times should I relight it?

Once, following the label on the unit. A second failure means something is wrong, and repeated relighting with a venting fault is unsafe.

Does a new thermocouple fix it every time?

No. It is the most common cause, but a blocked flue, a dirty pilot orifice or a failing gas control produces the same symptom.

Is it safe to use the heater if the pilot keeps going out?

Not if there is any smell of gas or a CO alarm. Leave the building and call the gas utility and 911 — that is not a service call.

Call(989) 601-2666